What’s the point of Dominic Raab?
Beware of unintended consequences
Why has Rishi Sunak made Dominic Raab his deputy prime minister, secretary of state for justice and lord chancellor?
Here are some suggestions:
Sunak wanted a competent performer to stand in for him at prime minister’s questions and this was the cabinet post that Raab demanded.
The prime minister concluded that Raab, despite being his notional deputy, would never pose a threat to Sunak’s own leadership.
Having decided he needed a broad-based cabinet drawn from different factions of the Conservative party, Sunak needed a lawyer who could keep Suella Braverman in her place and block any future attempts to speak outside her departmental brief.
He thought that the key to economic recovery and winning back Conservative support at the next general election would be to pass a long, obscure and much-derided bill to amend the Human Rights Act 1998 in a way that the government had been advised was largely unnecessary while making no change to the UK’s relationship with the European Court of Human Rights.
I don’t know whether any of these theories are true — though I have my doubts about the last one.
However, I’m much more confident that Sunak never considered the counter-argument:
The lord chancellor has a unique constitutional relationship with the lord chief justice of England and Wales. The Constitutional Reform Act 2005 was designed on the assumption that whoever was appointed to the post would understand the importance of this relationship in maintaining the rule of law. The holder would be decisive rather than dilatory; would take broad policy decisions rather than trying to micromanage; would understand the importance to the economy of the legal profession rather than allowing it to be run down by financial cuts; and would be cooperative rather than confrontational.
By those criteria, Brandon Lewis was doing rather well until he was sacked yesterday.
A Lawyer Writes is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.